Insights

Five email flows, and when to use them

Forget vanity metrics. The automated sequences that do the selling, how to set them up, and the ways they quietly go wrong.

Topic
Email Marketing
Published
22 Jul 2024
Reading time
9 min read
A woman smiling at an email on her phone

Plenty of shops treat email as a newsletter: new products, sale announcements, sent every week or two. That has its place, but it leaves the most useful work undone.

Automated flows do what newsletters can't: they send the right message to the right person at the moment it's relevant, triggered by what that person just did. Same list, same products, same brand. Once they're built, they run every day without anyone pressing send.

Here are the five flows that matter, in order of priority: abandoned cart, welcome, post-purchase, browse abandonment and win-back.

Abandoned cart: start here

People add things to cart, get distracted, leave. Some of them were never going to buy. But a lot of them just needed a nudge.

Be clear about who you can reach. A flow triggered when someone starts checkout only reaches people who typed their email address in. A flow triggered on add-to-cart reaches more people, but only if your platform can identify them, usually because they clicked through from an earlier email or are logged in. Anonymous visitors can't be emailed at all.

That's why the maths is smaller than it first looks. Say 200 people a day start checkout and 60 finish. That's 140 abandoned checkouts. Suppose half of those left an email address you're allowed to market to: 70 people. If the flow brings back one in ten of them, that's 7 orders a day, about 210 over a 30-day month. Those are assumptions, not a forecast; plug in your own numbers.

The flow itself is simple. Email one goes out about an hour after abandonment. Treat that as a starting setting and test it against how long people usually take to decide on your products. Just remind them what they left. Show the product image. Make it easy to get back to checkout. Don't offer a discount yet.

Email two, about 24 hours later, addresses objections. Remind them about free returns. Show a review of the product they were looking at. Answer whatever question might be stopping them.

Email three, maybe 48 to 72 hours later, is where you can offer an incentive if you want to. Free delivery or 10% off, time-limited. Some shops skip this entirely because they don't want to train customers to abandon carts for discounts. That's a reasonable position.

One thing I'd push back on: don't offer discounts in email one. You'll condition people to abandon carts on purpose, and that habit is slow to undo.

Every message in this flow needs the same exit condition: if the person places an order, they leave the flow immediately. Without it, people get 'you left something behind' an hour after their order confirmation, which is the fastest way to look careless.

Welcome sequence: your best shot at converting

Someone just signed up for your email list. Maybe they used a pop-up discount, maybe they opted in for something else. Either way, this is peak interest. They're thinking about you right now.

Plenty of shops send a discount code and then nothing until the next newsletter. Waste of an opportunity.

Email one should go out immediately. Deliver whatever you promised: discount code, free guide, whatever. Short brand intro. Clear path to shop.

Email two, next day, is your story. Why does this brand exist? What's different about you? People buy from brands they connect with. This is your chance to make that connection before they forget who you are.

Email three, maybe three days in, is social proof. Customer reviews, photos from customers, the questions people asked before buying and the answers. Reduce the perceived risk of buying from a brand they don't know yet.

Email four, around day five, showcases bestsellers. Make it easy for them to find something they'll love.

Email five, if they still haven't bought, is a reminder that the discount is about to expire. Only say that if the code does expire. A deadline that quietly resets is a fake deadline, and customers notice.

Anyone who buys partway through should drop out of the sequence and into post-purchase. A new customer getting 'still thinking about it?' two days after their first order is a common and avoidable mistake.

Post-purchase: where repeat customers are made

For a lot of shops, the second order is where a customer starts to be worth what it cost to acquire them. Before you build anything, check your own repeat rate: of the customers whose first order was at least a year ago, what share have ordered again? That number tells you how much this flow matters to you.

Order confirmation is transactional, not marketing. But a few days after delivery, check in. Did it arrive okay? Are they happy? Soft ask for a review.

A week or two later, send usage tips. How to get more value from what they bought. Care instructions. Styling ideas if it's fashion. No hard sell in this one; it's there to make the product work for them.

Two to three weeks after purchase, ask for a review properly. Make it one-click easy, with a direct link to the review form. The easier you make it, the more reviews you'll get.

Four to six weeks out, cross-sell. 'Customers who bought X also love Y.' Based on what they purchased, what's the logical next thing? This is your warmest audience.

Segment by product if you can. Someone who bought skincare needs different follow-up than someone who bought furniture, and consumables need replenishment timing rather than a cross-sell.

Take a coffee roaster as an example of how one of these is specified.

  • Trigger: an order containing a 250g bag of beans.
  • Eligibility: the customer has agreed to marketing email and isn't already on a coffee subscription.
  • Timing: at 15g a cup and two cups a day, a 250g bag lasts about eight days, so the reminder goes about a week after delivery, not after the order. Three bags last about 25 days, so someone who bought three shouldn't hear from you for about three weeks.
  • Exit: they place another coffee order, from any channel you can see.
  • Purpose: remind them before they run out, and mention the subscription once.

Before it sends, check the product is in stock. A 'time to reorder' email for beans you've sold out of sends people straight to a competitor.

Browse abandonment: tread carefully

Someone looked at a product but didn't add to cart. You can email them about it, but only in narrow circumstances.

You need to know who they are, which usually means they've clicked through from one of your emails before or are logged in. They need to have agreed to marketing email. And they shouldn't already be in another flow. Suppress anyone who has an open abandoned cart, anyone who bought in the last few days, and anyone you've already sent a browse email to this week. Send only when you can identify the person, they've agreed to marketing email, and none of those suppression conditions applies.

Done well, it's helpful: 'spotted something you liked?' with the product they viewed. Done poorly, it's creepy. 'We noticed you looked at...' sent 20 minutes after browsing feels like surveillance.

I'd wait at least a couple of hours. Keep the tone light and casual. One email, maybe two at most. Show the product they viewed, maybe some similar items in case that one wasn't quite right.

Expect this flow to convert less well than abandoned cart, which makes sense: these people were earlier in the buying journey.

For smaller shops, I'd build this after the first three. Get abandoned cart, welcome and post-purchase working well first.

And if your entire range is about five products, skip this one. It's awkward to send 'we noticed you viewed...' when there are only five things they could have viewed.

Win-back: reactivate before they forget

Customers go cold. Life happens, they find alternatives, they forget about you. Win-back sequences try to bring them back.

Timing matters. Start too early and you're nagging. Start too late and they've completely forgotten you. Base it on your own data rather than a rule: look at the typical gap between a customer's first and second order, and start the win-back once that gap has comfortably passed. A shop selling dog food and a shop selling sofas need very different answers.

Email one: 'We miss you.' Show what's new since they last shopped. Remind them why they bought from you in the first place.

Email two, maybe two weeks later: offer an incentive. An exclusive 'come back' discount. Make them feel valued.

Email three, another couple of weeks: 'Last chance.' Stronger offer. After this, if they don't engage, stop sending them regular emails for a while. Sending to people who never engage hurts your deliverability.

Judge engagement on clicks and site visits as well as opens. Apple's Mail Privacy Protection makes many opens look like they happened when they didn't, so an 'engaged' segment built on opens alone is flattering you.

High-value lapsed customers might warrant personal outreach. An email from a real person, not a marketing automation. Sometimes that's what it takes.

Getting these set up

If you're starting from zero, do them in this order: abandoned cart, welcome, post-purchase, then browse abandonment and win-back. The first three do most of the work for the effort.

You'll need an email platform that supports behavioural triggers. Klaviyo is the common choice for Shopify shops, and for good reason: the integration is solid and the flow builder is clear. Omnisend is fine too. Whatever you use, make sure it's connected to your shop and syncing properly. A broken integration fails silently: the flows simply stop sending, and nothing tells you.

Most of what goes wrong with flows is mechanical rather than creative:

  • Duplicate sends, when someone qualifies for two flows at once and gets both. Decide which flow wins.
  • Wrong events, such as a cart flow triggering on page views because the tracking was set up badly.
  • Messages after purchase, because the exit condition is missing or the order event arrives late.
  • Stockouts, where the email features a product you can't sell.
  • Replenishment timed from the order date instead of delivery, or ignoring how much was bought.
  • Weak suppression, so unsubscribed, bounced or recently complained-about contacts keep getting caught.

Measure revenue, not open rates, which automated opens make unreliable. To compare subject lines, split a send at random and judge each version on clicks and orders. Revenue tells you if your email programme is working. But read the platform's revenue figure for what it is: it credits the flow with any order placed within a set window after someone opened or clicked, including people who would have bought anyway. That's attributed revenue, not extra revenue.

To get closer to the real effect, hold back a small random group of eligible people from a flow and compare how much they buy with the group that got the emails. And when a flow uses a discount, compare contribution between the two groups after product costs and the discounts actually given. Check whether the platform's revenue figure is already net of the discount, so you don't deduct it twice.

And don't set and forget. These run automatically, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't look at them. Review performance monthly, check each flow has sent recently, test subject lines, and update content when products change or go out of stock.

How we help: E-commerce Management · Conversion Rate Optimisation

Want to talk this through for your own business? Dax reads every message personally and usually replies within a day.

Tell us what you need

Or get the next article by email, every couple of weeks.

Let's find a way forward

Dax reads every enquiry personally.

Step 1 of 4

What would you like to improve?

Choose the closest fit. We’ll help you turn it into a useful brief.